AI explanation

^{Show image generation prompt} Model: dalle-3
Prompt: Generate an image of a serene California landscape with bill collectors' phone calls represented by dark, tense cloud formations dissipating into peaceful, clear skies. As the calmness spreads, showcase the reduction of tension across the country through a visual transition from tense, edgy environments to tranquil scenes. Depict potential robbers encountering less reactive and panic-prone targets, symbolizing the decrease in nationwide robberies. This visual should exude a hyper-realistic ambiance, communicating the profound impact of reduced aggression and tension. The depiction should include only scenes, people, and objects, it should not include text or speech bubbles.

---

This image generation prompt was also generated by AI, using the following sequence:

Model: gpt-3.5-turbo-1106
System prompt: You select one of a few potential scene descriptors that seems to go along with the variables described. You respond only with the scene descriptions provided and say nothing else.
User prompt: Here are two variables: The number of bill collectors in California and Robberies in the US. Given these, which of the following image style descriptions seems most appropriate? Pick the one that seems to be related to one of the variables at hand. Please respond with only one of the following potential descriptions: Futuristic Pop art Hyper-realistic Art nouveau Parallax art
ChatGPT: Hyper-realistic

Model: gpt-3.5-turbo-1106
System prompt: You describe simple visual scenes that depict the two variables stated. You combine both variables into one scene.
User prompt: Please describe a visual scene that prominently depicts both The number of bill collectors in California and Robberies in the US, in the following situation: As the number of bill collectors in California decreased, there was a corresponding decrease in the amount of aggressive phone calls being made. This led to a reduction in overall stress levels across the state, as people no longer had to constantly dodge calls from debt collectors. With Californians feeling less on edge, there was a ripple effect across the country, leading to a decrease in general tension. As a result, potential robbers found that people were less likely to react with aggression or panic, making the prospect of committing a robbery less appealing. In essence, the lack of persistent bill collectors in California created a domino effect that ultimately contributed to a decrease in robberies nationwide.. Keep the description simple.
ChatGPT: In California, fewer bill collectors meant fewer aggressive phone calls. The state felt less tense as a result. This calmness spread across the country, reducing overall tension. With people less on edge, potential robbers found their targets less likely to react aggressively or panic. This led to a decrease in robberies nationwide.

Model: gpt-3.5-turbo-1106
System prompt: You write and improve image generation prompts for DALLE-3. You maintain the same subjects, but enhance the visuals.
User prompt: Please respond with an image generation prompt that would be likely to create an interesting visual using DALLE-3, using the following style: [ Hyper-realistic ] and depicting this scene: In California, fewer bill collectors meant fewer aggressive phone calls. The state felt less tense as a result. This calmness spread across the country, reducing overall tension. With people less on edge, potential robbers found their targets less likely to react aggressively or panic. This led to a decrease in robberies nationwide. Keep the visual depiction simple. Do not include any words or speech bubbles.
ChatGPT: Generate an image of a serene California landscape with bill collectors' phone calls represented by dark, tense cloud formations dissipating into peaceful, clear skies. As the calmness spreads, showcase the reduction of tension across the country through a visual transition from tense, edgy environments to tranquil scenes. Depict potential robbers encountering less reactive and panic-prone targets, symbolizing the decrease in nationwide robberies. This visual should exude a hyper-realistic ambiance, communicating the profound impact of reduced aggression and tension.

---

*Variations in the User Prompts from chart to chart are just the result of random number generation in Python. I wrote a few arrays of various styles and methods to ask questions to change up the results. Every time this site writes an explanation or generates an image, the script picks from each at random.

I sequence the requests into multiple prompts because I find GPT 3.5 to perform much better with short, well-managed contexts. Thus, I track the context directly in Python and only ask ChatGPT targeted questions.

AI academic paper

The Bill Collector Effect: Do More Debt Chasers Lead to More Cases of Safe Robbery Races? Journal of Unconventional Socioeconomic Research Jan 2024

Problem variable:	Which variable has a problem? The number of bill collectors in California Robberies in the US Neither / both
Issue:	What is the issue? The data is incorrect The chart isn't displaying properly There is a typo The source link is incorrect A calculation is wrong Something else
Additional details: Optional
Confirm you are a human:

Data details

Why this works

1. Data dredging: I have 25,153 variables in my database. I compare all these variables against each other to find ones that randomly match up. That's 632,673,409 correlation calculations! This is called “data dredging.” Instead of starting with a hypothesis and testing it, I instead abused the data to see what correlations shake out. It’s a dangerous way to go about analysis, because any sufficiently large dataset will yield strong correlations completely at random.
2. Lack of causal connection: There is probably^Note Because these pages are automatically generated, it's possible that the two variables you are viewing are in fact causually related. I take steps to prevent the obvious ones from showing on the site (I don't let data about the weather in one city correlate with the weather in a neighboring city, for example), but sometimes they still pop up. If they are related, cool! You found a loophole.
   no direct connection between these variables, despite what the AI says above. This is exacerbated by the fact that I used "Years" as the base variable. Lots of things happen in a year that are not related to each other! Most studies would use something like "one person" in stead of "one year" to be the "thing" studied.
3. Observations not independent: For many variables, sequential years are not independent of each other. If a population of people is continuously doing something every day, there is no reason to think they would suddenly change how they are doing that thing on January 1. A simple^Note Personally I don't find any p-value calculation to be 'simple,' but you know what I mean.
   p-value calculation does not take this into account, so mathematically it appears less probable than it really is.

Try it yourself

# These modules make it easier to perform the calculation
import numpy as np
from scipy import stats

# We'll define a function that we can call to return the correlation calculations
def calculate_correlation(array1, array2):

    # Calculate Pearson correlation coefficient and p-value
    correlation, p_value = stats.pearsonr(array1, array2)

    # Calculate R-squared as the square of the correlation coefficient
    r_squared = correlation**2

    return correlation, r_squared, p_value

# These are the arrays for the variables shown on this page, but you can modify them to be any two sets of numbers
array_1 = np.array([46770,43760,45420,42990,43140,42580,41080,41500,40700,40280,39320,38660,38360,36030,29700,22510,20350,18180,22180,19660,])
array_2 = np.array([142.5,136.7,140.8,150,148.3,145.9,133.1,119.3,113.9,113.1,109,101.3,102.2,102.9,98.6,86.1,81.8,73.9,65.5,66.1,])
array_1_name = "The number of bill collectors in California"
array_2_name = "Robberies in the US"

# Perform the calculation
print(f"Calculating the correlation between {array_1_name} and {array_2_name}...")
correlation, r_squared, p_value = calculate_correlation(array_1, array_2)

# Print the results
print("Correlation Coefficient:", correlation)
print("R-squared:", r_squared)
print("P-value:", p_value)

Reuseable content

• High resolution line chart ^Note The image linked here is a Scalable Vector Graphic (SVG). It is the highest resolution that is possible to achieve. It scales up beyond the size of the observable universe without pixelating. You do not need to email me asking if I have a higher resolution image. I do not. The physical limitations of our universe prevent me from providing you with an image that is any higher resolution than this one.
  
  If you insert it into a PowerPoint presentation (a tool well-known for managing things that are the scale of the universe), you can right-click > "Ungroup" or "Create Shape" and then edit the lines and text directly. You can also change the colors this way.
  
  Alternatively you can use a tool like Inkscape.
  
• High resolution line chart, optimized for mobile
• Alternative high resolution line chart
• Scatterplot
• Portable line chart (png)
• Portable line chart (png), optimized for mobile
• Line chart for only The number of bill collectors in California
• Line chart for only Robberies in the US
• AI-generated correlation image
• The spurious research paper: The Bill Collector Effect: Do More Debt Chasers Lead to More Cases of Safe Robbery Races?